This 5,000-Square-Foot Pre-War Penthouse in NY's Upper West Side Had Custom Furniture Craned In Over Manhattan — It's a Unique Retreat From the City

Connected to the floor below, this family-friendly home is filled with warmth, character, and clever design details

A neutral living room in a penthouse with a balcony running around it with a glass balustrade with two matching wood coffee tables in the center of mirroring armchairs and a sofa
(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

Following a chance encounter on Instagram, CA-based interior designer Lindye Galloway, founder of her eponymous design studio, was tasked with redesigning this 5,000-square-foot historic pre-war penthouse in New York's Upper West Side, in collaboration with Foubister Architects.

The clients, a couple with two young children, purchased the penthouse and the floor below it wanting to connect the floors to create a modern home that was unique, family-friendly, and inherently functional.

A modern neutral living room with a built-in fireplace with a textured wall and wooden storage and shelving next to it behind two dark brown modern armchairs

From the ceiling treatment to the wall behind the fireplace, this seating space is filled with texture.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

The clients wanted the home to be filled with design and character while also maximizing every inch of space. The custom millwork and marble features that are carried throughout the home, from cozy nooks to built-in storage, add modern warmth and elegance.

"My favorite element of the design process was being able to envision this home with the cityscape all around while creating a space that was calming, had statements, but also gave the city line the ability to be a strong feature," says Lindye.

A modern timber kitchen with fluted detailing on the cabinetry, a marble worktop, a black wall-hung tap and a display shelf below two small brass-based wall lights with white pleated shades

There are so many subtle details that add interest and warmth in this modern kitchen.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

The wood kitchen cabinetry is crafted from rift white oak in a dead-flat finish for a more natural look, and the delicate paneled detailing adds a refined texture to the design.

"The lighting is a cluster of custom lights we designed with beautiful glass that creates a subtle statement," explains Lindye. "The island is very long, so this gave a unique look to the lighting element that felt less traditional and made a statement in the long space."

A modern timber kitchen with fluted detailing on the cabinetry, a marble worktop and island with several pendant lights hanging above and with built-in seating on the dining table side

"The kitchen pendants give a beautiful clustered, structural feel while not overwhelming the space," says Lindye.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

The idea to connect the dining area to the kitchen island was to create a more intimate feel within the expanse of this larger open-plan space. "It also gave the great room two designated areas, which felt more appropriate for the size of the penthouse, versus lots of furniture floating in the middle," explains Lindye.

A modern neutral living room in a penthouse with a city view from large sliding glass doors leading to a balcony with two wooden coffee tables and beige armchairs

The ceiling treatment in this seating area was created to make the space feel like a "designated spot" in the wider open-plan living area. "We felt like this ceiling treatment defined that side of the great room. This helped give it uniqueness and consistency to the two seating areas," says Lindye.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

The redesign was not, however, without its challenges. As the home is in a pre-war building, the elevator was small, meaning the only way to bring in the large, custom pieces of furniture was by crane. "Almost every piece was craned over Manhattan and into the penthouse," says Lindye. "In addition to it being the top floor, there were additional issues we had to work around, one being the post in the kitchen and living room."

A modern neutral living room with built-in storage, cream walls, wooden paneled ceiling, a slim, modern, black-lined chandelier and a striped rug below the brown sofa and white armchairs with piping

This living room is quietly elegant with subtle details that add character.

Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway

An entryway with wood detailing throughought from the slim paneled door to the panels behind the console table and the wood flooring

As with all the wood used in this project, the wood detailing in the entryway is crafted from rift white oak.

Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway

"The downstairs living room creates a cozy additional hangout area that I think is really nice for intimate gatherings," says Lindye of her favorite room in the home. The earthy color palette carried across the project ensures the calm, cozy feel is felt from one room to the next in this cohesive design. "We used custom stains on the millwork but kept [the color palette] pretty consistent throughout, so that there was a nice thread across the two stories of the home," shares Lindye.

A hallway leading to the main doorway of a penthouse with skylights above and built-in cabinetry along one side of the wall with two cream rugs on the wooden flooring

Skylights were added to the hallway, along with a great deal of built-in storage. "We created the hallway extra wide so it didn’t feel like a tunnel," explains Lindye.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

A curved, built-in niche in a modern bedroom is clad in pale wood for a cozy reading nook, with three small wall lights, behind a small seating area with two cream armchairs in front of a round table

The custom-built niche in the primary bedroom adds real design flair to this space.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

A neutral modern bedroom with cream walls, pendant lighting, a piece of art hangs between the two windows facing the bed which has armchairs in front of it

"The primary bedroom furnishings give a real custom, built-in feel with a serene touch," Lindye says.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

The cozy bedroom offers multiple areas to lounge and relax, true of every space across the home, from the seating arrangement at the foot of the bed complete with a small coffee table, to the elegant, built-in niche with integrated bench seating and delicate wall lights. It's layered with texture, adding depth, comfort, and warmth.

A modern neutral bedroom with a large curved headboard, a curved wooden bedside table and a wooden door with ribbed detailing in the center

The curved headboard has a wood border with floral-patterned upholstery for a true statement piece.

(Image credit: Mike Van Tassell. Design: Lindye Galloway)

The guest bedroom's dramatic, custom-built headboard makes for an elegant focal point. "It was built in three separate pieces and then individually hung to the wall. It creates a statement on the entirety of the wall, and we love how it connects the bed and nightstands, says Lindye.

"We wanted to create a unique niche instead of a blank wall," explains Lindye, of the primary bathroom wall viewed from the bedroom. "We like that the arch gave it character, and it added additional storage. It created a pretty focal point in the bathroom." The conservatory-style shower gives a spa-like feel to the space and a unique point of interest.

The overall feel of the home has a characterful, retreat-like quality — a place to escape to for calm and comfort away from the chaos of the city below.


For more inspiring home tours and design ideas, why not subscribe to the Livingetc newsletter?

Debbie Black
Deputy Editor (Digital)

Debbie is Livingetc's deputy editor (digital). She embarked on her career in the publishing industry almost 20 years ago, with experience spanning interiors and fashion brands across both print and digital platforms.

She has worked for titles including ELLE Decoration, World of Interiors, ELLE, Condé Nast Traveller, GQ, and Glamour, among others. She is a lover of all things interiors and loves planning a makeover project. She can often be found moving furniture and decor around her house for the millionth time or else watering her 50 houseplants!